#151 — /talkback/ ... /file_view of a comment does not present the comment

by Graham Perrin — last modified Jan 07, 2009 11:37 AM
State Unconfirmed
Version:
—
Area Functionality
Issue type Bug
Severity Low
Submitted by Graham Perrin
Submitted on Dec 06, 2007
Responsible
—
Target release:
—
Return to tracker
First reported (probably mistakenly) in Plone Trac at
http://dev.plone.org/plone/ticket/7451

----

Recent Changes portlet draws attention to recent comments (talkback), but following such links reveals

 * no comment

 * a simple view (but not the normal view) of the parent object.

Taking two steps back in the breadcrumb trail does leads to the object, with comments visible, so for me this is a trivial bug.

As background: re http://plone.org/products/arfilepreview/issues/12 I first noticed an issue (error) whilst ARFilePreview was installed. Whilst ARFilePreview remains in the Products directory, it's no longer installed.

Regards
Graham
Added by Graham Perrin on Dec 06, 2007 05:23 PM
Version is Ploneboard 2.0b1. Please let me know if you'd like any additional information.
Added by Graham Perrin on Dec 06, 2007 05:25 PM
Version is Ploneboard 2.0b1. Please let me know if you'd like any additional information.
Added by Graham Perrin on Dec 07, 2007 09:52 PM
Under http://plone.org/products/arfilepreview/issues/12 atReal wrote:

> Actually, when you go _on_ a comment object, you get an url that
> _should_ display the main object with all its comments
Added by Graham Perrin on Dec 09, 2007 12:44 AM
See also http://plone.org/products/plonehelpcenter/issues/86

-- that is, another issue affecting comments, related to a different product.
Added by Jeff Pittman on Jan 28, 2008 10:14 AM
For comments in 3.0.5 (Ploneboard 2.0rc1 installed; intra/extra wf), when you see links in /recently_modified, you get a link like http://mysite/myfolder/mypage/talkback/1201490873, but when you visit a link, it doesn't show the page with the comment, just the page by itself, with no Add Comment button and no comments shown. So you have to read the title and click the page in the nav to see the comments. Such talkback links into Ploneboard work fine.
Added by Jeff Pittman on Jan 28, 2008 10:19 AM
For comments in 3.0.5 (Ploneboard 2.0rc1 installed; intra/extra wf), when you see links in /recently_modified, you get a link like http://mysite/myfolder/mypage/talkback/1201490873, but when you visit a link, it doesn't show the page with the comment, just the page by itself, with no Add Comment button and no comments shown. So you have to read the title and click the page in the nav to see the comments. Such talkback links into Ploneboard work fine.

No responses can be added.